Instructional coaching theory and practice: The proof is in the pudding.


The implementation of instructional coaches is a relatively new concept. As with instructional design, the field of education has modified coaching from its sports and business roots to meet the needs of students within a traditional classroom. Marzano and Simms (2013) explained that the purpose of an instructional coach is to help teachers better their practice by providing strategies that help students and develop specific action plans to correct areas that are in need of improvement. With this idea in mind, instructional coaches do not assume administerial roles; rather, they act as guides to help lead teachers to develop their instructional practice. Therefore, instructional coaches help teachers and administrators adopt a growth mindset through which they provide support to help teachers reach their full potential. However, for instructional coaching to be successful, schools must develop specific supports to help teachers maintain their level of practice.

Aguilar (2011) argued they are four essential conditions for instructional coaching to be successful: school culture, structures for collaboration, principal’s view of coaching, and professional development of coaches. You can access her blog post by following this link: http://www.edutopia.org/blog/four-conditions-instructional-coaching-elena-aguilar. Marzano and Simms (2013) reported that many people believe the most important component of instructional coaching is the coachee. In this regard, a school culture that is responsive to change and open to engaging in difficult conversations must be established. Teachers within the school must be willing to analyze assessment data and take it face value, so they use that information formatively to improve their classroom instruction. Likewise, a culture of resistance in which teachers attempt to ‘explain away’ data must be avoided in order to truly have a transformative experience. Reeves (2007) reported, “the first requirement of effective coaching is that the person receiving the coaching agrees that a change in performance will be useful" (as cited in Marzano & Simms, 2013, p. 9). Therefore, a school culture where data and self-assessment are valued must be established before instructional coaching will be successful. Therefore, in regard to instructional coaching practice, instructional coaches must develop data meetings and PLCs in which data analysis is meaningful and purposeful. This is necessary to develop buy-in from teachers. If the instructional coaches are unable to get teachers to see the importance of analyzing student data and engaging in self-assessment, then the rest of the coaching cycle will be seen as a waste of time and effort. Likewise, principals need to see instructional coaching as valuable tool to help improve the level of instructional practice throughout the building.

Specifically, principals should make a concerted effort to express the importance of evaluating student progress and responding to areas that need improvement. Marzano and Simms (2013) argued that principals should not force teachers to work with instructional coaches; rather, they should focus on the teacher’s identified area of growth and offer instructional coaching as a way to help reach their goal. In this sense, instructional coaches should be viewed as an additional tool to provide support for teachers. Furthermore, instructional coaching cycles should not be used punitively; instead, they should be used as a comprehensive tool to better a teacher’s instructional practice.

Likewise, opportunities for collaboration should be provided to develop further the relationship between instructional coach and coachee. Marzano and Simms (2013) argued that trust is an essential component regarding the development of coaching relationships. In order to develop trust, teachers and coaches must have time to collaborate with one another through purposeful conversations in regard to student performance. These intimate conversations in regard to student data will help establish trust between the instructional coach and coachee. The establishment of trust within the relationship will help the instructional coach and the coachees have difficult conversations about areas in which the coachee may struggle.

Aguilar (2011) argued that professional development opportunities are critical component for the practice of instructional coaches as well. Both teachers and instructional coaches must see themselves as lifelong learners in order to reach their full potential as teachers and instructional coaches. Marzano and Simms (2013) argued that one of the jobs of instructional coaches is to help teachers transfer their knowledge from professional development to their classrooms. Likewise, instructional coaches need professional development that helps them act as facilitator through the transference of knowledge from the professional development to the classroom.

Although there is not an abundance of empirical data for the use of instructional coaches in a school system, many would attest that instructional coaches provide many benefits for a school. However, in order for instructional coaching to be successful, coaches must take theory regarding instructional coaching to develop a practical plan for application.




References


Aguilar, E. (2011, May 20). Four conditions essential for instructional coaching to work. [Web log comment]. Retrieved from http://www.edutopia.org/blog/four-conditions-instructional-coaching-elena-aguilar


Marzano, R. and Simms, J. (2013). Coaching classroom instruction. Bloomington, IN: Marzano Research Laboratory.


Reeves, D.B. (2007). Coaching myths and realities. Educational Leadership, 65(2), 89-90.