The Right Choice


The mission and vision for the Shelby County School district is to make every student a graduate and every graduate prepared. With that in mind, school leaders must be mindful of learning opportunities that differ from the traditional classroom setting. The increase of technology throughout the school district has brought an opportunity for administrators and teachers to approach learning through a digital lens. Specifically, educators within our system have the opportunity to digitize their courses, allowing students an alternative to the traditional “sit and get" method of teaching. Although the system is not prepared to offer courses designed for exclusive asynchronous learning, they are prepared to offer courses through a blended learning model that require participants to engage digitally with the course materials and other participants, making strides toward exclusively digital learning. Additionally, the Shelby County School district rely on digital content and delivery as a major prong for the response to intervention process, allowing teachers to differentiate the learning for students. Additionally, it is paramount that regular parent contact is made in regard to student progress in an effort to increase stakeholder awareness and participation in the learning process. Therefore, the school district must choose a robust learning management system that allows teachers to deliver content digitally while providing differentiated instruction for students. Based on these requirements, the Edgenuity learning system would be an excellent system to use because it focuses on using digital content to target intervention to students while frequently contacting parents in regard to student progress. Furthermore, it scores well in regard to the other indicators identified by Simonson, Smaldino, and Svacek and the Advanced Distributed Learning Initiative. A few of the characteristics to consider when choosing a learning management system (LMS) are highlighted in this infographic.

Although the infographic is intended to help businesses and other private organizations choose an appropriate LMS, education systems must be cognisant of those characteristics as well. Specifically, the integration and interface of an LMS is something that should be considered before purchasing. A LMS that is not user-friendly will cause teachers to become frustrated and could cause them to abandon the LMS. Likewise, if the LMS does not integrate well digital systems, like the Google Apps suite, teachers may use the LMS less frequently because they already have a familiarity with the other product. The initial analysis of Edgenuity indicates the LMS is easy to use, providing explicit instruction to the different functions of the product. Furthermore, it is web-based, which allows instructors and students to access course material from their homes, at school, and on a variety of devices. Edgenuity’s ease of use and the system’s ability to respond to individual student needs is demonstrated in this video.

Additionally, the following categories were considered when choosing the LMS: instructional design, teaching, students, support materials, and assessments.

Instructional design

Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) explained, “consider all aspects of the instructional environment, following a well-organized procedure that provides guidance to even the novice distance instructor... The instructional environment should be viewed as a system, a relationship among and between all the components of that system—the instructor, the learners, the material, and the technology (128)." The Edgenuity learning management system takes this concept into consideration in regard to instructional design. The system provides explicit instructions for teachers allowing them to develop a relationship with the students. Likewise, Edgenuity provides specific objectives that align with Common Core State Standards. Teachers can base their instruction on these objectives providing the best opportunity for students.

Teaching

Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) argued in addition to well-defined objectives, instructors of blended and distance learning courses must provide opportunities for the students to communicate with both the instructor and each other. Edgenuity embeds this capability within the system. This allows students to engage with the instructor and the material developing their understanding of the course objectives.

Students

Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) explained that ease of access is important for students to be able to engage with the course material. This increased access inundates the students with the materials increasing student engagement. Edgenuity is web-based, which means that students can access the material from virtually anywhere. With the ease of accessibility, students can correct misconceptions quickly, increasing their understanding of the material.

Support Materials

Berking and Gallagher (2016) listed support several support materials as being critical to choosing a learning management system. These support materials provide appropriate scaffolding for students throughout the course, and well-designed materials can aid in the overall understanding of the course material. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) argued that interactive graphic organizers are an important support material, which can be used to support student learning. Not only does Edgenuity provide interactive graphic organizers, it also differentiates the graphic organizers based on student comprehension levels. This amount of differentiation positively impacts student learning by helping the student organize the information at his or her own cognitive level.

Assessment

Berking and Gallagher (2016) explained that learner tracking is an important component to any learning management system. Specifically, they argued that administrators should not only track comprehension of the material but engagement as well. Generally speaking, engaged learners have a tendency to retain information over longer time periods. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) support this idea as well, arguing that different learning behaviors should be tracked in addition to direct learning. In this regard, assessment and learner tracking are the strongest components of the Edgenuity system. Edgenuity provides a robust system of assessment that allows class facilitators to assess student understanding and engagement with course materials. Likewise, the system can prescribe differentiated instruction based on the student understanding of the material or provide additional course materials, like videos, to engage disengaged learners. This capability is especially important for the Shelby County School district because it their goal to provide a substantive response to intervention system that addresses the needs of all learners.

Overall, the Edgenuity learning management system attends to all of the needs of the Shelby School district. Although it does not integrate well with third party applications, it does provide a robust differentiation system that provides multiple opportunities for student intervention. Furthermore, the system has access to a large supply of support materials designed to engage all types of learners, making it the best fit for Shelby County Schools.

References

Berking, P. and Gallagher, S. (2016, 4 November). Choosing a Learning Management System. Retrieved from .

Simonson, M., Smaldino, S., and Zvacek, S. (2015). Teaching and Learning at a distance: Foundations of distance education (6th ed.). Charlotte, North Carolina: Information Age Publishing.