Virtual Schooling 3-2-1

Distance learning has developed rapidly since I was a child. I still remember television commercials for art courses where participants would mail their work to instructors. Now, students can effectively complete a course using mobile applications on their smart phones. Virtual technologies continue to be developed, and virtual citizens have created unique forms of writing through blogging and tweeting. Schools are taking advantage of these technologies by developing entire virtual programs. These virtual programs continue to be developed at an astonishing rate.
The Surprises
In fact, the rapid development and growth of virtual programs is one the most surprising discoveries I made in regard to virtual learning. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) reported virtual schools are growing at an exponential rate. Furthermore, the federal government requires public schools to offer a virtual option for students who would like to study through virtual courses. Through many of these courses, participants can engage in asynchronous learning, consequently closing the temporal gap, which could limit the number of participants. This concepts contrasts greatly with my own experience with distance learning as a high school student. Although to me it does not seem that long ago, I remember studying through distance learning by videocasting to another school in my district using our closed-circuit networking capabilities. Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013) reported that virtual school enrollment has increased from nearly zero enrolled students in 2000- my freshman year of high school to 200,000 students by 2012.
(Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013)
Likewise, my freshman class at the University of Alabama piloted a blended learning math class that required us to complete virtual modules, while meeting with instructors once a week. Now, high school students can complete courses across the state without having to meet face-to-face with the instructor. This drastic changed occurred within a decade.
Another surprising idea I learned in regard to virtual schooling is the number of learning management systems available for use. I did not realize the choice school systems have in regard to what type of learning management system they will use for their students. In college, the primary learning management system used by the University of Alabama was Blackboard Connect. Although this learning management system is still competitive it is only one of many. So far this year, I have used several different types of learning management systems including Canvas, Moodle, Google Classroom, and Edgenuity. Each has its own unique features, but they all have the capability of offering different courses that are customizable. The following chart is a comparison of just a few of the learning management systems available.
LMS comparison.png
The last characteristic of virtual learning that surprised me was the difficulty in creating pedagogically sound, well-designed courses. Many of the instructors in the interviews we viewed reported they spent more time developing their virtual courses than their traditional courses despite having access to preloaded content. I felt the same in my own experience developing the introductory activity to my course. Initially, I felt I had created a well-planned and thoughtful assignment; however, I learned that I was missing crucial components that would provide clarity for my participants. In this regard, “the devil is in the details." Virtual course instructors must provide detailed and specific steps to guide their students because they lack the face-to-face communication that most students get in a traditional classroom. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) argued that non-traditional communication may be the most difficult challenge for distance education, which is why developing a discourse with students is important in a virtual course.
The Concerns
The first concern I have with virtual learning is the disproportionate number of hispanic students enrolled in virtual courses. According to Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013), only about 47% of hispanic students are enrolled in virtual courses compared to traditionally enrolled students in the United States, which is less than the other demographics. This discrepancy could be caused by a language barrier, but in this digital age, many of the learning management systems have a built in translation system that could be used. A concerted effort should be made to increase the enrollment of hispanic students in virtual courses in the United States.
The biggest concern I have in regard to virtual schooling is the poor academic performance of virtual students in regard to standardized testing. Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013) reported in 2012 many virtual schools were not meeting adequate yearly progress; and furthermore, virtual schools reported a graduation rate of only 37.5%. Kamenetz (2015) reported virtual schools scored poorly on outcome measures. Essentially, virtual programs do not perform as well as their traditional counterparts. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) reported disengagement to be a critical issue for virtual learning. I would assume this is the case in regard to virtual K-12 schools as well. As professional, I find it difficulty to manage online coursework, and I would imagine it would be even more difficult for younger students. Therefore, students should strive to increase communication with their instructor and cohort members in order to develop their understanding of the material and to encourage one another throughout the duration of the course.
The Questions
How can virtual courses be developed to address the needs of courses, like biology and chemistry, that require participants to complete laboratory modules? I know there are some courses that offer virtual labs; however, I have found those labs to pale in comparison to traditional labs. Is it just too expensive and dangerous to send laboratory materials to students? Could students participate video web-conferencing tools? Is the participation valid experience? I ask these questions strictly for personal reasons. I became ill while in school, and I did not have a strong enough immune system to participate in labs. I had to postpone my graduation because I physically could not enter the laboratory. Participating virtually would have meant that I could graduate on time and saved me a lot of money. It would be interesting to this in the future.
References
Kamenetz, (2 February, 2015). Virtual schools bring real concerns about quality. [Radio broadcast episode]. <http://www.npr.org/templates/transcript/transcript.php?storyId=382167062>
Miron, G., Horvitz, B., and Gulosino, C. (2013). Virtual schools in the U.S. 2013: Politics, performance, policy, and research evidence. National Education Policy Center: University of Colorado, Boulder, CO.
Simonson, M., Smaldino, S., and Zvacek, S. (2015). Teaching and Learning at a distance: Foundations of distance education (6th ed.). Charlotte, North Carolina: Information Age Publishing.


Conflicting modification on June 24, 2017 at 8:34:30 PM:

Distance learning has developed rapidly since I was a child. I still remember television commercials for art courses where participants would mail their work to instructors. Now, students can effectively complete a course using mobile applications on their smart phones. Virtual technologies continue to be developed, and virtual citizens have created unique forms of writing through blogging and tweeting. Schools are taking advantage of these technologies by developing entire virtual programs. These virtual programs continue to be developed at an astonishing rate. l

The Surprises

In fact, the rapid development and growth of virtual programs is one the most surprising discoveries I made in regard to virtual learning. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) reported virtual schools are growing at an exponential rate. Furthermore, the federal government requires public schools to offer a virtual option for students who would like to study through virtual courses. Through many of these courses, participants can engage in asynchronous learning, consequently closing the temporal gap, which could limit the number of participants. This concepts contrasts greatly with my own experience with distance learning as a high school student. Although to me it does not seem that long ago, I remember studying through distance learning by videocasting to another school in my district using our closed-circuit networking capabilities. Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013) reported that virtual school enrollment has increased from nearly zero enrolled students in 2000- my freshman year of high school to 200,000 students by 2012.

(Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013)

Likewise, my freshman class at the University of Alabama piloted a blended learning math class that required us to complete virtual modules, while meeting with instructors once a week. Now, high school students can complete courses across the state without having to meet face-to-face with the instructor. This drastic changed occurred within a decade.

Another surprising idea I learned in regard to virtual schooling is the number of learning management systems available for use. I did not realize the choice school systems have in regard to what type of learning management system they will use for their students. In college, the primary learning management system used by the University of Alabama was Blackboard Connect. Although this learning management system is still competitive it is only one of many. So far this year, I have used several different types of learning management systems including Canvas, Moodle, Google Classroom, and Edgenuity. Each has its own unique features, but they all have the capability of offering different courses that are customizable. The following chart is a comparison of just a few of the learning management systems available

LMS comparison.png

The last characteristic of virtual learning that surprised me was the difficulty in creating pedagogically sound, well-designed courses. Many of the instructors in the interviews we viewed reported they spent more time developing their virtual courses than their traditional courses despite having access to preloaded content. I felt the same in my own experience developing the introductory activity to my course. Initially, I felt I had created a well-planned and thoughtful assignment; however, I learned that I was missing crucial components that would provide clarity for my participants. In this regard, “the devil is in the details." Virtual course instructors must provide detailed and specific steps to guide their students because they lack the face-to-face communication that most students get in a traditional classroom. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) argued that non-traditional communication may be the most difficult challenge for distance education, which is why developing a discourse with students is important in a virtual course.

The Concerns

The first concern I have with virtual learning is the disproportionate number of hispanic students enrolled in virtual courses. According to Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013), only about 47% of hispanic students are enrolled in virtual courses compared to traditionally enrolled students in the United States, which is less than the other demographics. This discrepancy could be caused by a language barrier, but in this digital age, many of the learning management systems have a built in translation system that could be used. A concerted effort should be made to increase the enrollment of hispanic students in virtual courses in the United States.

The biggest concern I have in regard to virtual schooling is the poor academic performance of virtual students in regard to standardized testing. Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013) reported in 2012 many virtual schools were not meeting adequate yearly progress; and furthermore, virtual schools reported a graduation rate of only 37.5%. Kamenetz (2015) reported virtual schools scored poorly on outcome measures. Essentially, virtual programs do not perform as well as their traditional counterparts. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) reported disengagement to be a critical issue for virtual learning. I would assume this is the case in regard to virtual K-12 schools as well. As professional, I find it difficulty to manage online coursework, and I would imagine it would be even more difficult for younger students. Therefore, students should strive to increase communication with their instructor and cohort members in order to develop their understanding of the material and to encourage one another throughout the duration of the course.

The Questions

How can virtual courses be developed to address the needs of courses, like biology and chemistry, that require participants to complete laboratory modules? I know there are some courses that offer virtual labs; however, I have found those labs to pale in comparison to traditional labs. Is it just too expensive and dangerous to send laboratory materials to students? Could students participate video web-conferencing tools? Is the participation valid experience? I ask these questions strictly for personal reasons. I became ill while in school, and I did not have a strong enough immune system to participate in labs. I had to postpone my graduation because I physically could not enter the laboratory. Participating virtually would have meant that I could graduate on time and saved me a lot of money. It would be interesting to this in the future.

References

Kamenetz, (2 February, 2015). Virtual schools bring real concerns about quality. [Radio broadcast episode].

Miron, G., Horvitz, B., and Gulosino, C. (2013). Virtual schools in the U.S. 2013: Politics, performance, policy, and research evidence. National Education Policy Center: University of Colorado, Boulder, CO.

Simonson, M., Smaldino, S., and Zvacek, S. (2015). Teaching and Learning at a distance: Foundations of distance education (6th ed.). Charlotte, North Carolina: Information Age Publishing.