What is instructional design?
Instructional design provides focus to a lesson or training by targeted a specific skill and developing measurable objectives to ensure that the skill of concept has been taught to fidelity. Good instructional design includes detailed analysis of needs assessments to determine deficiencies while providing intentional instructional strategies that address the needs of individual learners in the training. Furthermore, trainers must include an assessment measure to identify concepts that need clarification and further instruction. Specifically, a detailed, formulaic model can be applied during instructional design providing the best experience for the learner.
Likewise, Yanchar and Hawkley (2015) argued that instructional designers improve their practice through informal learning, which included discussions with other instructional designers, subject matter experts, and thorough analysis of available products. Through the discussion and analysis of different techniques and models, the instructional designers were able to self-reflect, developing trainings that pulled from practical applications of the techniques discussed in theoretical classes. In this regard, the practice of instructional design is one in which practitioners are constantly evaluating and manipulating their training modules to better suit the needs of the learners. Piskurich (2015) explained that analysis is an integral component to several phases of instructional design models. Specifically, instructional designers must analyze data in regard to not only the identified or perceived need of the institution, but they must be aware of the learners within their training as well in order to provide the most beneficial experience for the participants.
The constant analysis and evaluation used to develop trainings provides an advantage for the use of instructional design by allowing instructional designers to manipulate their programs or modules based on the immediate need of the institution or the individual needs of the learners; this provides concise and meaningful learning for the participants. However, Piskurich (2015) suggested that the amount of time and effort that trainers put into their instructional design may cause them to be unwilling to manipulate their design when their analysis indicates their current model is ineffective. This reluctance could be potentially problematic because the instructional design would not reflect the need of the individual or organization. Despite this disadvantage, when instructional design is completed to fidelity without personal prejudice, it yields substantial results, which benefit both the organization and the individual participant.
The best of example of outstanding instructional design that I have experienced was through AMSTI training, which was partnered with the University of Montevallo. Each day, the instructor posted clear, measurable objectives that were assessed intermittently throughout the training. Furthermore, the instructor used scenario-based instructional strategies that allowed the participants to engage with the material, developing a practical understanding of the learning objectives. Before each break, the instructor gave informal formative assessments to measure our understanding of the material, and she addressed areas of misconceptions with the individuals who were having difficulty, differentiating the material to allow others to move at a faster pace. Each of these elements not only provided a pleasurable experience for the participants, but it provided specific guidance as to how to use the training once returning to the classroom. Although the video is designed to demonstrate the effective use of learning targets, it is a good example as to why defining learning objectives important for instructional designers.
Using a Learning Target throughout a Lesson from EL Education on https://vimeo.com">Vimeo.
On the other hand, I have experienced training that lacked the elements of good instructional design completely. Specifically, I participated in a dyslexia training that did not attend to the level of knowledge of the participants, consequently forcing participants to sit through explanations of dyslexia that they are already knew. The instructor did not post measurable objectives, so it was difficult to identify the purpose of the presentation. Also, the instructor did not measure the acquisition of knowledge, so she did not know if we understood the training or not. Unfortunately, I left the training confused as to what I was supposed to do with the information that was presented.
Excellent content presentation is no substitute for quality instructional design, which is why most school systems have adopted instructional practices that model instructional design techniques. Through thorough analysis of the needs of the organization and the development of a detailed action plan, instructional designers are able to create robust trainings that meet the needs of all participants while focusing on a specific goal for the betterment of the entire organization.
References
Piskurich, G. M. (2015). Rapid instructional design: Learning ID fast and right. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
Yanchar, S. C. & Hawkley, M. N. (2015). Instructional design and professional informal learning: Practices, tensions, and ironies. Educational Technology & Society, 18(4), 424–434.