What strategy works for you?

With a traditional “sit and get" training, participants rarely have an opportunity to engage with information and learning. Consequently, this passive learning inadequately prepares the trainees for the practical application of the information. In short, the method by which the information is delivered is incongruent with the intended use of the information. Piskurich (2015) explained that good instructional designers choose delivery methods that align with the course of objectives. Therefore, if the objectives for the course are performance-based, then the delivery method of the information should reflect the need for the learners to be active participants in order to complete the learning objectives. As a result of the active learning process, participants will develop a more in-depth understanding of the material. Specifically, there are two strategic learning strategies that do an excellent job of engaging learners: case- based (project-based) learning and scenario-based learning. Through each of these strategies, learners are given the opportunity to think critically about the information while using their newly acquired knowledge to solve an essential question or problem.
Cased-based learning or problem-based learning is a strategic learning strategy in which participants are given a specific task or problem to complete. In juxtaposition to “sit and get" training, the participants are tasked with struggling with the information to solve the problem, consequently enriching their understanding of the source material. With this type of strategy, the trainer acts as a facilitatory, clarifying information when necessary, providing guidance when participants are unable to solve a specific component of the problem, and debriefing the participants in regard to the information acquired throughout the learning. Abraham, Damanhuri, and Salehuddin (2016) explained problem-based learning increased self-directed learning in medical students by requiring participants to define their own objectives and outcomes during the learning process, enriching their understanding of the content. Furthermore, Yoo and Park (2015) argued problem-based learning helped foster communication and critical-thinking among nursing school participants. Using case-based (problem-based) learning during trainings has provided opportunities for my faculty members to engage with the information, while developing their communication and critical-thinking skills. Specifically, the teachers were tasked with disaggregating assessment data and developing a screening flowchart that could be used universally throughout the school in order to identify struggling students. The only parameters that were given for the activity were the types of assessments and the percent of students who needed to be identified to adequately service our student population. Teachers worked collaboratively with one another, analyzing the data and developing a comprehensive system that could be used to identify struggling students. This training was successful because initially, the teachers were overwhelmed with the disaggregation of the data; however, throughout the process, the teachers became comfortable with the data analysis. This allowed them to develop a specific program to address the needs of our school while acquiring the data analysis skills needed to address student concerns in their individual classrooms. This is the completed screening flowchart.
Screening Flow Chart (1).png

Similarly, scenario-based learning provides opportunities for learners to actively engage in the learning process through simulation. As with case-based learning, participants have the opportunity to engage with the content knowledge in order to complete a specific task. However, scenario-based learning adds an opportunity to include a technology component as well. Piskurich (2015) argued blended learning opportunities are more successful. Scenario-based learning provides blended learning by utilizing the strategies of case-based learning with a digital learning environment. Furthermore, scenario-based learning provides a protected, digital environment for participants while allowing them to use the information contextually. I had the opportunity to participate in a scenario-based learning opportunity while learning lab safety in college. The professor gave each group of students a specific scenario in which they had to use their knowledge of laboratory procedures to develop a solution. The action steps were entered into a computer program that allowed students to see the results of their actions without causing any harm to the participants. This type of learning is crucial because it developed critical-thinking skills in a high stress situation without the fear of causing harm to the students. Communication was essential during this process, encouraging collaboration among group members and other teams throughout. Likewise, the active engagement and practical application of the information provided greater context for lab safety instructions, emphasizing the importance of proper technique during actual labs.
Through each learning strategy, participants are able to engage in the information providing greater context. The practical application of the information allows the participants to develop their own unique understanding of the information, providing unique perspectives for class discussion. Additionally, both types of trainings encourage the development of critical-thinking skills and collaboration, creating a rich learning experience for the participants.


References

Abraham, R. R., Hassan, S., Ahlam Damanhuri, M. U., & Salehuddin, N. R. (2016). Exploring students' self-directed learning in problem-based learning. Education In Medicine Journal, 8(1), 15-23. doi:10.5959/eimj.v8i1.377


Piskurich, G. M. (2015). Rapid instructional design: Learning ID fast and right. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.

Yoo, M., & Park, H. (2015). Effects of case-based learning on communication skills, problem-solving ability, and learning motivation in nursing students. Nursing & Health Sciences, 17(2), 166-172. doi:10.1111/nhs.12151