You're not in it alone!
Instructional coaches fulfill a unique niche within a school. They are required to be transformational leaders by helping teachers improve their teaching practice; however, they have to fulfill this obligation without the ability to require mandates or directives. Without this administrative privilege, it is crucial for instructional coaches to develop and maintain a relationship with their mentee teachers that promotes an environment of self-reflection and growth. This environment helps move teachers along the continuum for their specific growth goal. Therefore, instructional coaches must use strategic approaches when developing these relationships as to not damage the rapport with the teacher while ensuring the teachers are taking the appropriate actions to improve their instruction. Marzano and Simms (2013) reviewed specific aspects of instructional coaching practice to help coaches enter and maintain appropriate relationships with teachers. Specifically, developing coaching conversations and modeling are the two aspects that were crucial for the development of my coaching relationship.
As an administrator, it was difficult for me to develop an appropriate coaching relationship. The teacher for which I engaged in a coaching cycle is my subordinate. That relationship was already established before beginning the coaching cycle. I had to develop a completely different relationship with this teacher while maintaining the administrator-teacher relationship. The establishment of the coaching relationship was necessary because I did not want this teacher to view the coaching strategies as directives, rather I wanted the teacher to view the coaching process strictly as a learning experience to improve their instructional practice. The primary tool in developing this relationship was dialogue. The conversation I developed had to move from a directing conversation to a facilitating and coaching conversation. Word choice was paramount in developing the appropriate conversation in order to reach the desired outcome. I intentionally removed the personal pronoun ‘you’ from the conversation; and instead, I used collective personal pronouns, establishing the idea of a team. Cornett et al. (2009) explained, “no teacher faces an instructional challenge alone" (p. 27). It is important for that teacher to understand that the development of his instructional practice is a group effort.
Furthermore, Marzano and Simms (2013) explained modeling is an important aspect of the coaching process. In order to identify a growth goal for the teacher, I asked him to complete a likert scale, which would place him on the continuum in regard to learning targets. He had completed my previous training on learning targets, and he scored himself high in regard to developing student-friendly learning targets from the standards and his ability to differentiate between a learning objective and a learning target. However, he identified he was not comfortable in developing student buy-in and ownership of the learning target. Therefore, we developed a growth goal that would address his concern. I presented him several strategies in regard to developing student ownership of the standard and we discussed the research that supported these strategies as well. He chose learning target annotation as his next step, so I modeled that process for him, so he could see the strategy in action. As I modeled the strategy, we discussed why each of the different components of strategy were important. He explained that he heard the why of the learning targets on many different occasions, but it never quite clicked until he was able to see the strategy in action. In essence, he needed me to differentiate my instruction based on his specific learning style. When I was able to engage him in this way, he better understood my success criteria for successful implementation of the learning target. This proved that modeling the strategy was necessary in developing understanding. It is simply not enough to tell teachers what to do, rather instructional coaches should be prepared to show and teach along with their mentee teachers. An excellent example of modeling is presented in the video. Although it focuses on modeling strategies for students, the same concept can be applied when modeling strategies for teachers.
References
Marzano, R. and Simms, J. (2013). Coaching classroom instruction. Bloomington, IN: Marzano Research Laboratory.
Cornett, J., Ellison, J., Hayes, C., Killion, J., Kise, J., Knight, J., Reinke, W.M….West, L. (2009). Coaching: Approaches and perspectives. J. Knight (Ed.) Thousand Oaks, Ca: Corwin Press.