Dustin Smith

Dustin Smith

Using Technology for Data Collection and Individualizing Student Learning


Free stock photo of idea, creativity, bubble, bulb



The Consortium for School Networking (CoSN) (2018) advocates for an instructional technology framework that is built upon three pillars: Leadership and Vision, Understanding the Educational Environment, and Managing Technology and Support Resources. Each of these pillars is critical to the effective implementation of instructional technology within a school district. Likewise, the framework is not effective if these pillars are not used in concert with one another to develop a clear vision and implementation strategy for technology use within a district and the local school level as well. As an assistant principal, I have participated in each pillar, supporting technology use at both the local and district levels. One of the most in-depth projects I have managed using the CoSN framework was the development of technology protocols that allowed teachers to record, monitor, and evaluate data in regard to students who were involved in the Problem Solving Team (PST) process. Specifically, I developed an electronic tool to record data that allowed PST members to track student progress using a running record, while helping them engage in both face-to-face and electronic discussions about student progress.


Tomlinson (2014) argued technology provides multiple tools in which data can be collected and evaluated to develop differentiated educational experiences for students. Likewise, the PST process provides an opportunity for teachers to collect data in regard to student to performance in order to develop individualized plans for students to improve student learning outcomes, or develop a strategic plan for individual students that will allow them to be more successful later on in their academic careers. Young (2006) explained that some teachers make loose connections in regard to data, using inappropriately to make decisions about students. Similarly, Stecker (2017) observed that despite having access to data, some teachers continued to disregard the data when making instructional decisions. To combat both inadequate data analysis and simple refusal to use data to inform instructional decisions, school leaders must engage in persistent dialogue with teachers in regard to data, encouraging them to use it to make decisions in regard to student learning.

With these ideas in mind, I created a PST document and protocol that not only encouraged teachers to analyze student data but engage in a dialogue about the data to develop a strategic action plan. A template of the document can be viewed below.

The data cards were developed using a V-lookup function that aggregated the several data sources to make the process easier for teachers. The document was then shared with the teachers on the student PST. Teachers used the document to have electronic discussions in regard to best teaching strategies for that student. Furthermore, they collected their own data and commented on the student’s data card to show a clear picture of the strategies that were successful and those that were not.

CoSN Framework (2018) asks that instructional technology leaders establish tools and practices to collect and store data. The data cards I developed for PST provides a resource for teachers to collect data from multiple sources while storing that data in a shared location to promote communication among the student’s PST members. Additionally, the CoSN Framework (2018) promotes the use of technology to meet the needs of all students. In this regard, the data cards allowed the teachers to develop a strategic PST plan that differentiated learning for that student by providing research-based instructional strategies to help close the learning gaps for that student. Teachers had the ability to provide leveled texts for students who struggled with reading on grade-level or provide opportunities for the student to re-attempt work in order for them to master a specific standard. The teachers recorded the progress of these strategies on the data card, painting a clear picture of the necessary tools to make the student successful. Lastly, the CoSN Framework (2018) encourages collaborative communication among educators. This type of communication was recorded on the data cards as an electronic dialogue between PST members. The communication provided adequate data when some of the students had to be referred for special education services because it was evident that a clearly defined standard was established early on and teachers used data to inform their instructional decisions in regard to the student.


References

CoSN, (2018). Framework of essential skills of the k-12 CTO. Retrieved from .


Stecker, P. M. (2017). Reflections on Teachers' Data-Based Decision Making. Learning Disabilities Research & Practice (Wiley-Blackwell), 32(1), 71-72. doi:10.1111/ldrp.12128


Tomlinson, C.A. (2014). The differentiated classroom: Responding to the needs of all learners (2nd ed.). Alexandria, VA.: ASCD


Young, VM 2006, 'Teachers' Use of Data: Loose Coupling, Agenda Setting, and Team Norms', American Journal of Education, 112(4), 521-548.



Virtual Schooling 3-2-1

Distance learning has developed rapidly since I was a child. I still remember television commercials for art courses where participants would mail their work to instructors. Now, students can effectively complete a course using mobile applications on their smart phones. Virtual technologies continue to be developed, and virtual citizens have created unique forms of writing through blogging and tweeting. Schools are taking advantage of these technologies by developing entire virtual programs. These virtual programs continue to be developed at an astonishing rate.
The Surprises
In fact, the rapid development and growth of virtual programs is one the most surprising discoveries I made in regard to virtual learning. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) reported virtual schools are growing at an exponential rate. Furthermore, the federal government requires public schools to offer a virtual option for students who would like to study through virtual courses. Through many of these courses, participants can engage in asynchronous learning, consequently closing the temporal gap, which could limit the number of participants. This concepts contrasts greatly with my own experience with distance learning as a high school student. Although to me it does not seem that long ago, I remember studying through distance learning by videocasting to another school in my district using our closed-circuit networking capabilities. Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013) reported that virtual school enrollment has increased from nearly zero enrolled students in 2000- my freshman year of high school to 200,000 students by 2012.
(Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013)
Likewise, my freshman class at the University of Alabama piloted a blended learning math class that required us to complete virtual modules, while meeting with instructors once a week. Now, high school students can complete courses across the state without having to meet face-to-face with the instructor. This drastic changed occurred within a decade.
Another surprising idea I learned in regard to virtual schooling is the number of learning management systems available for use. I did not realize the choice school systems have in regard to what type of learning management system they will use for their students. In college, the primary learning management system used by the University of Alabama was Blackboard Connect. Although this learning management system is still competitive it is only one of many. So far this year, I have used several different types of learning management systems including Canvas, Moodle, Google Classroom, and Edgenuity. Each has its own unique features, but they all have the capability of offering different courses that are customizable. The following chart is a comparison of just a few of the learning management systems available.
LMS comparison.png
The last characteristic of virtual learning that surprised me was the difficulty in creating pedagogically sound, well-designed courses. Many of the instructors in the interviews we viewed reported they spent more time developing their virtual courses than their traditional courses despite having access to preloaded content. I felt the same in my own experience developing the introductory activity to my course. Initially, I felt I had created a well-planned and thoughtful assignment; however, I learned that I was missing crucial components that would provide clarity for my participants. In this regard, “the devil is in the details." Virtual course instructors must provide detailed and specific steps to guide their students because they lack the face-to-face communication that most students get in a traditional classroom. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) argued that non-traditional communication may be the most difficult challenge for distance education, which is why developing a discourse with students is important in a virtual course.
The Concerns
The first concern I have with virtual learning is the disproportionate number of hispanic students enrolled in virtual courses. According to Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013), only about 47% of hispanic students are enrolled in virtual courses compared to traditionally enrolled students in the United States, which is less than the other demographics. This discrepancy could be caused by a language barrier, but in this digital age, many of the learning management systems have a built in translation system that could be used. A concerted effort should be made to increase the enrollment of hispanic students in virtual courses in the United States.
The biggest concern I have in regard to virtual schooling is the poor academic performance of virtual students in regard to standardized testing. Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013) reported in 2012 many virtual schools were not meeting adequate yearly progress; and furthermore, virtual schools reported a graduation rate of only 37.5%. Kamenetz (2015) reported virtual schools scored poorly on outcome measures. Essentially, virtual programs do not perform as well as their traditional counterparts. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) reported disengagement to be a critical issue for virtual learning. I would assume this is the case in regard to virtual K-12 schools as well. As professional, I find it difficulty to manage online coursework, and I would imagine it would be even more difficult for younger students. Therefore, students should strive to increase communication with their instructor and cohort members in order to develop their understanding of the material and to encourage one another throughout the duration of the course.
The Questions
How can virtual courses be developed to address the needs of courses, like biology and chemistry, that require participants to complete laboratory modules? I know there are some courses that offer virtual labs; however, I have found those labs to pale in comparison to traditional labs. Is it just too expensive and dangerous to send laboratory materials to students? Could students participate video web-conferencing tools? Is the participation valid experience? I ask these questions strictly for personal reasons. I became ill while in school, and I did not have a strong enough immune system to participate in labs. I had to postpone my graduation because I physically could not enter the laboratory. Participating virtually would have meant that I could graduate on time and saved me a lot of money. It would be interesting to this in the future.
References
Kamenetz, (2 February, 2015). Virtual schools bring real concerns about quality. [Radio broadcast episode]. <http://www.npr.org/templates/transcript/transcript.php?storyId=382167062>
Miron, G., Horvitz, B., and Gulosino, C. (2013). Virtual schools in the U.S. 2013: Politics, performance, policy, and research evidence. National Education Policy Center: University of Colorado, Boulder, CO.
Simonson, M., Smaldino, S., and Zvacek, S. (2015). Teaching and Learning at a distance: Foundations of distance education (6th ed.). Charlotte, North Carolina: Information Age Publishing.


Conflicting modification on June 24, 2017 at 8:34:30 PM:

Distance learning has developed rapidly since I was a child. I still remember television commercials for art courses where participants would mail their work to instructors. Now, students can effectively complete a course using mobile applications on their smart phones. Virtual technologies continue to be developed, and virtual citizens have created unique forms of writing through blogging and tweeting. Schools are taking advantage of these technologies by developing entire virtual programs. These virtual programs continue to be developed at an astonishing rate. l

The Surprises

In fact, the rapid development and growth of virtual programs is one the most surprising discoveries I made in regard to virtual learning. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) reported virtual schools are growing at an exponential rate. Furthermore, the federal government requires public schools to offer a virtual option for students who would like to study through virtual courses. Through many of these courses, participants can engage in asynchronous learning, consequently closing the temporal gap, which could limit the number of participants. This concepts contrasts greatly with my own experience with distance learning as a high school student. Although to me it does not seem that long ago, I remember studying through distance learning by videocasting to another school in my district using our closed-circuit networking capabilities. Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013) reported that virtual school enrollment has increased from nearly zero enrolled students in 2000- my freshman year of high school to 200,000 students by 2012.

(Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013)

Likewise, my freshman class at the University of Alabama piloted a blended learning math class that required us to complete virtual modules, while meeting with instructors once a week. Now, high school students can complete courses across the state without having to meet face-to-face with the instructor. This drastic changed occurred within a decade.

Another surprising idea I learned in regard to virtual schooling is the number of learning management systems available for use. I did not realize the choice school systems have in regard to what type of learning management system they will use for their students. In college, the primary learning management system used by the University of Alabama was Blackboard Connect. Although this learning management system is still competitive it is only one of many. So far this year, I have used several different types of learning management systems including Canvas, Moodle, Google Classroom, and Edgenuity. Each has its own unique features, but they all have the capability of offering different courses that are customizable. The following chart is a comparison of just a few of the learning management systems available

LMS comparison.png

The last characteristic of virtual learning that surprised me was the difficulty in creating pedagogically sound, well-designed courses. Many of the instructors in the interviews we viewed reported they spent more time developing their virtual courses than their traditional courses despite having access to preloaded content. I felt the same in my own experience developing the introductory activity to my course. Initially, I felt I had created a well-planned and thoughtful assignment; however, I learned that I was missing crucial components that would provide clarity for my participants. In this regard, “the devil is in the details." Virtual course instructors must provide detailed and specific steps to guide their students because they lack the face-to-face communication that most students get in a traditional classroom. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) argued that non-traditional communication may be the most difficult challenge for distance education, which is why developing a discourse with students is important in a virtual course.

The Concerns

The first concern I have with virtual learning is the disproportionate number of hispanic students enrolled in virtual courses. According to Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013), only about 47% of hispanic students are enrolled in virtual courses compared to traditionally enrolled students in the United States, which is less than the other demographics. This discrepancy could be caused by a language barrier, but in this digital age, many of the learning management systems have a built in translation system that could be used. A concerted effort should be made to increase the enrollment of hispanic students in virtual courses in the United States.

The biggest concern I have in regard to virtual schooling is the poor academic performance of virtual students in regard to standardized testing. Miron, Horvitz, and Gulosino (2013) reported in 2012 many virtual schools were not meeting adequate yearly progress; and furthermore, virtual schools reported a graduation rate of only 37.5%. Kamenetz (2015) reported virtual schools scored poorly on outcome measures. Essentially, virtual programs do not perform as well as their traditional counterparts. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) reported disengagement to be a critical issue for virtual learning. I would assume this is the case in regard to virtual K-12 schools as well. As professional, I find it difficulty to manage online coursework, and I would imagine it would be even more difficult for younger students. Therefore, students should strive to increase communication with their instructor and cohort members in order to develop their understanding of the material and to encourage one another throughout the duration of the course.

The Questions

How can virtual courses be developed to address the needs of courses, like biology and chemistry, that require participants to complete laboratory modules? I know there are some courses that offer virtual labs; however, I have found those labs to pale in comparison to traditional labs. Is it just too expensive and dangerous to send laboratory materials to students? Could students participate video web-conferencing tools? Is the participation valid experience? I ask these questions strictly for personal reasons. I became ill while in school, and I did not have a strong enough immune system to participate in labs. I had to postpone my graduation because I physically could not enter the laboratory. Participating virtually would have meant that I could graduate on time and saved me a lot of money. It would be interesting to this in the future.

References

Kamenetz, (2 February, 2015). Virtual schools bring real concerns about quality. [Radio broadcast episode].

Miron, G., Horvitz, B., and Gulosino, C. (2013). Virtual schools in the U.S. 2013: Politics, performance, policy, and research evidence. National Education Policy Center: University of Colorado, Boulder, CO.

Simonson, M., Smaldino, S., and Zvacek, S. (2015). Teaching and Learning at a distance: Foundations of distance education (6th ed.). Charlotte, North Carolina: Information Age Publishing.


The Right Choice


The mission and vision for the Shelby County School district is to make every student a graduate and every graduate prepared. With that in mind, school leaders must be mindful of learning opportunities that differ from the traditional classroom setting. The increase of technology throughout the school district has brought an opportunity for administrators and teachers to approach learning through a digital lens. Specifically, educators within our system have the opportunity to digitize their courses, allowing students an alternative to the traditional “sit and get" method of teaching. Although the system is not prepared to offer courses designed for exclusive asynchronous learning, they are prepared to offer courses through a blended learning model that require participants to engage digitally with the course materials and other participants, making strides toward exclusively digital learning. Additionally, the Shelby County School district rely on digital content and delivery as a major prong for the response to intervention process, allowing teachers to differentiate the learning for students. Additionally, it is paramount that regular parent contact is made in regard to student progress in an effort to increase stakeholder awareness and participation in the learning process. Therefore, the school district must choose a robust learning management system that allows teachers to deliver content digitally while providing differentiated instruction for students. Based on these requirements, the Edgenuity learning system would be an excellent system to use because it focuses on using digital content to target intervention to students while frequently contacting parents in regard to student progress. Furthermore, it scores well in regard to the other indicators identified by Simonson, Smaldino, and Svacek and the Advanced Distributed Learning Initiative. A few of the characteristics to consider when choosing a learning management system (LMS) are highlighted in this infographic.

Although the infographic is intended to help businesses and other private organizations choose an appropriate LMS, education systems must be cognisant of those characteristics as well. Specifically, the integration and interface of an LMS is something that should be considered before purchasing. A LMS that is not user-friendly will cause teachers to become frustrated and could cause them to abandon the LMS. Likewise, if the LMS does not integrate well digital systems, like the Google Apps suite, teachers may use the LMS less frequently because they already have a familiarity with the other product. The initial analysis of Edgenuity indicates the LMS is easy to use, providing explicit instruction to the different functions of the product. Furthermore, it is web-based, which allows instructors and students to access course material from their homes, at school, and on a variety of devices. Edgenuity’s ease of use and the system’s ability to respond to individual student needs is demonstrated in this video.

Additionally, the following categories were considered when choosing the LMS: instructional design, teaching, students, support materials, and assessments.

Instructional design

Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) explained, “consider all aspects of the instructional environment, following a well-organized procedure that provides guidance to even the novice distance instructor... The instructional environment should be viewed as a system, a relationship among and between all the components of that system—the instructor, the learners, the material, and the technology (128)." The Edgenuity learning management system takes this concept into consideration in regard to instructional design. The system provides explicit instructions for teachers allowing them to develop a relationship with the students. Likewise, Edgenuity provides specific objectives that align with Common Core State Standards. Teachers can base their instruction on these objectives providing the best opportunity for students.

Teaching

Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) argued in addition to well-defined objectives, instructors of blended and distance learning courses must provide opportunities for the students to communicate with both the instructor and each other. Edgenuity embeds this capability within the system. This allows students to engage with the instructor and the material developing their understanding of the course objectives.

Students

Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) explained that ease of access is important for students to be able to engage with the course material. This increased access inundates the students with the materials increasing student engagement. Edgenuity is web-based, which means that students can access the material from virtually anywhere. With the ease of accessibility, students can correct misconceptions quickly, increasing their understanding of the material.

Support Materials

Berking and Gallagher (2016) listed support several support materials as being critical to choosing a learning management system. These support materials provide appropriate scaffolding for students throughout the course, and well-designed materials can aid in the overall understanding of the course material. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) argued that interactive graphic organizers are an important support material, which can be used to support student learning. Not only does Edgenuity provide interactive graphic organizers, it also differentiates the graphic organizers based on student comprehension levels. This amount of differentiation positively impacts student learning by helping the student organize the information at his or her own cognitive level.

Assessment

Berking and Gallagher (2016) explained that learner tracking is an important component to any learning management system. Specifically, they argued that administrators should not only track comprehension of the material but engagement as well. Generally speaking, engaged learners have a tendency to retain information over longer time periods. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) support this idea as well, arguing that different learning behaviors should be tracked in addition to direct learning. In this regard, assessment and learner tracking are the strongest components of the Edgenuity system. Edgenuity provides a robust system of assessment that allows class facilitators to assess student understanding and engagement with course materials. Likewise, the system can prescribe differentiated instruction based on the student understanding of the material or provide additional course materials, like videos, to engage disengaged learners. This capability is especially important for the Shelby County School district because it their goal to provide a substantive response to intervention system that addresses the needs of all learners.

Overall, the Edgenuity learning management system attends to all of the needs of the Shelby School district. Although it does not integrate well with third party applications, it does provide a robust differentiation system that provides multiple opportunities for student intervention. Furthermore, the system has access to a large supply of support materials designed to engage all types of learners, making it the best fit for Shelby County Schools.

References

Berking, P. and Gallagher, S. (2016, 4 November). Choosing a Learning Management System. Retrieved from .

Simonson, M., Smaldino, S., and Zvacek, S. (2015). Teaching and Learning at a distance: Foundations of distance education (6th ed.). Charlotte, North Carolina: Information Age Publishing.


The Good, The Bad, and the Technologically Challenged

Historyofdistanceeducation.jpg
As indicated by the infographic, distance learning has progressed at an astonishing rate since the time of correspondence distance learning. Since the advent of digital tools, students have better access to course materials, and learning institutions have developed courses for students who are separated from the learning institution geographically, temporally, or both. This access provides more opportunities for students to collaborate with their peers from around the world, developing a rich and robust learning community that draws from the varied experiences of the individuals in the course. Furthermore, the digital tools used in today’s distance learning courses provide an opportunity for instructors to differentiate modules for students by giving support or developing enrichment opportunities.
Daphne Koller explains in the following TED Talk video how developing distance learning courses has provided opportunities for students who would not be able to attend traditional universities while differentiating instruction through modules to support and scaffold student learning.
Distance learning best practices are evident throughout the video, and I have enrolled in courses that used these practices to support, providing a robust learning experience for everyone in the class. Specifically, the best experiences that I have had with distance learning are ones in which modules are broken down into smaller components that include video, reading, and response. These smaller modules provide digestible chunks of information that allow me to process the information in different ways. Additionally, the response components provide an opportunity to analyze misconceptions, so I can correct them before submitting the final product. Melton (2014) explained the development of behavior objectives is necessary component of distance learning courses; and specifically, one of the identified behavior objectives for distance learning courses is to engage in the material in varied ways. In alignment with this concept, instructors who develop smaller, more specific modules while including varied modalities by which to engage in the material provide their students with more enriching learning experiences. Furthermore, I have found that differentiating instruction based on my needs helps to create a more fulfilling learning experience. Specifically, I struggled with the concepts regarding the development of school infrastructure because I did not have the appropriate background in computer science. The additional course materials in regard to developing school networks allowed me to conduct my own independent research, providing me the ability to scaffold my own instruction appropriately without holding back the rest of my classmates who had a strong foundation in computer science. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) explained that differentiating instruction for individual students is a foundational principle for andragogy. In this regard, differentiation of course material is a reasonable expectation for distance learning instructors.
On the other hand, my bad experiences with distance education come when there are issues with communication. Simonson, Smaldino, Svacek (2015) explained that Holmberg’s Theory of Interaction and Communication places guided didactic conversation at the core of distance learning. Essentially, effective communication is responsible for the amount information that an individual will learn during a course. Students who actively engage in communication with their cohort have a tendency to learn more during the course than those who do not. Unfortunately, not all communication is equal. I have found that communication that promote conversational dialogue are more effective than those that require participants to comment back and forth on an assignment. Often times, the participants have to rely on the messaging service of the blogging tool he or she uses. Unfortunately, those messaging services are not always reliable, causing gaps in the dialogue. Likewise, communication tools that are difficult to use make effective communication difficult; and in these cases, many of the participants become frustrated, reflecting their frustration in their communication. Specifically, I have found that commenting back and forth on assignments is not the most effective form of communication. Classes that use a common platform for communication and designate specific time intervals for communication drastically improve communication and engagement with course materials. Specifically, Twitter chats and messaging platforms have been my favorite form of communicating because I am able to engage in conversations with specific members of my cohort from my mobile device. In fact, I was able to complete a chat session while waiting in line for an amusement park ride. It was convenient, and I was able to effectively communicate my argument using my phone and the digital textbook I downloaded on my phone.
References
Melton, R. (2014). Objectives, Competencies and Learning Outcomes: developing instructional materials in Open and Distance learning. Routledge.
Simonson, M., Smaldino, S., and Zvacek, S. (2015). Teaching and Learning at a distance: Foundations of distance education (6th ed.). Charlotte, North Carolina: Information Age Publishing.

Analyzing Technology Use




It is important for school technology leaders to self-assess in order determine areas of strengths and areas in need of improvement. This is analysis is not only essential for future technology purchasing, but it is also important in the creation of technology policies that promote substantive change throughout a school. Whitehead, Jensen, and Boschee (2013) argued that in order to do this, school leaders must have an accurate measure of what they are doing well and on areas of need of improvement. Furthermore, the analysis must be measured against a specific set of standards to determine an accurate picture. Whitehead, Jensen, and Boschee (2013) argued that the ISTE Essential Conditions provide an accurate description of how technology can be used substantively in a school. The ISTE Essential Conditions can be found here: ://www.iste.org/docs/pdfs/netsessentialconditions.pdf. If schools and school districts align their technology vision and mission to these conditions, then the school or district is ensuring that technology is being used substantively to enhance teaching and learning within the school. Additionally, Whitehead, Jensen, and Boschee (2013) argued that the best vision and mission statements combined both pedagogical and technological ideas to create a vision and mission that infuses each type of learning in the educational process. Therefore, an accurate measurement tool will be a tool in which the essential conditions are considered.

With the ISTE Essential Conditions in mind, the Technology Planning Analysis Rubric from the Technology Use Plan Primer by H. R. Sibley and Chip Kimball provides a comprehensive examination of the material, aligning most of the questions with the concepts covered in the essential conditions. Although the rubric itself, is not a product ISTE, the questions reflect the descriptors used in the ISTE Essential Conditions, indicating substantive use of technology. This is important for school districts because Whitehead, Jensen, and Boschee (2013) explained that the biggest barrier to widespread school technology implementation is for stakeholders to recognize quantifiable benefits for technology use within a school. Fortunately, the Technology Planning Analysis Rubric from the Technology Use Plan Primer by H. R. Sibley and Chip Kimball provides specific, measurable evidence for stakeholders. Hopefully, this evidence will encourage stakeholder buy-in in regard to developing programs for technology use within a school.

These technology programs, however, cannot be completed to fidelity without adequate professional development, which is one of the indicators measured by the rubric. Fortunately, as a whole, my school district does a really good job of providing continuous professional development for staff members. Machado and Chung (2015) explained that continuous professional development increased teacher technology efficacy, consequently leading to the development of lesson plans that integrate technology to enhance student learning. Without the analysis of technology using the Technology Planning Analysis Rubric from the Technology Use Plan Primer by H. R. Sibley and Chip Kimball, stakeholders would not be able to see how well the district provides professional development.

The analysis of technology plans is an essential component for any school or school district. Specifically, the district should use a rubric that measures proficiency using a specific set of standards like the ISTE Essential Conditions because these essential conditions provide a specific measurement of achievement. The district should then use this data to develop a strategic action plan for technology use that enhances student learning.



References

Machado, L.J. and Chung, C. J. (2015). Integrating technology: The principal’s role and effect International Education Studies, 8(5), 43-53.

Whitehead, B.M., Jensen, D.E.N., and Boschee, F. (2013). Planning for technology: A guide for school administrators, technology coordinators, and curriculum leaders. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press

Developing a Digital Citizenship Curriculum

Please checkout my VoiceThread on Developing a Digital Citizenship Curriculum.


Future-proofing Schools


network-cable-ethernet-computer-159304.jpeg

In order to adequately prepare for the future, Whitehead, Jensen, and Boschee (2013) explained that technology leaders and school administrators should evaluate the type of learning they want in the school and how technology is to be used in the school to enhance learning. Furthermore, Whitehead, Jensen, and Boschee (2013) encouraged school leaders to develop technology systems that provide enough flexibility to allow for several different types of programs if the identified program does not fit the needs of the school. Specifically, the infrastructure should fit like a mitten rather than a glove, providing flexibility in technology application. In other words, the technology infrastructure should not be developed around a single idea; it should support several different educational concepts to future-proof the school (Whitehead, Jensen, and Boschee, 2013, p. 200). The importance of developing a sound technology infrastructure is represented in the graphic. The infrastructure provides the foundation for other educational supports. Without it, teachers would be unable to use effectively technology to enhance student learning.

Technology infrastructure.png

Providing flexibility in regard to technology infrastructure is especially true when developing an elearning environment. Kuzo (2014) argued technology leaders need to consider both the cost effectiveness of the system and the flexibility in upgrading the system in the future. As online learning environments evolve, the infrastructure of the system must evolve as well. Therefore, administrators and technology leaders should purchase systems that have cost effective upgrades while having enough power to support elearning systems. Purchasing a large volume of cost effective equipment that cannot be updated could be fiscally irresponsible due to the purchase of new equipment every time it becomes outdated. Piskurich (2015) explained that the constant evolution of elearning environments it difficult to maintain in regard to instructional design, and this is also true for maintaining the appropriate infrastructure for those elearning environments. Equipment that can be upgraded, should be used whenever possible to keep up with the computing needs of these digital environments.

However, cloud-based systems allow users to store information within the cloud, allowing less powerful computers to work faster by freeing up RAM. Kuzo (2014) explained the use of cloud-based or onsite servers is another critical aspect of the infrastructure that must be considered when future-proofing a school. The use of cloud-based systems allows for the purchase of more cost effective equipment; however, Whitehead, Jensen, and Boschee (2013), explained the bandwidth of the school would need to be increased to account for a large volume of machines accessing the network at one time. Without continuous network access, users would have to store their data on the machine, which would decrease the speed at which the device can compute. With slower computing power, many of the devices would be rendered ineffective. Furthermore, cloud-based systems could become unresponsive with high influxes of data. The servers are maintained by a separate company, which prevents local informational technology personnel from troubleshooting the issue. In this case, an on-site server would be more effective because technicians would have the ability to troubleshoot on site. In, short a combination of both on site servers and cloud-based systems should be developed to provide the greatest flexibility for the infrastructure with the least of amount of risk.

In order to effectively future-proof a school, school technology leaders should develop flexible, upgradeable infrastructures that meet the demand for a constantly evolving learning environment. Technology use is now engrained education, providing students with more opportunities than ever thought possible, which is why a strong and flexible infrastructure must be established.



References


Kuzo, J. (2014, November 11). Four critical decisions when making wireless infrastructure changes. [web log comment]. Retrieved from https://www.edutopia.org/discussion/four-critical-decisions-when-making-wireless-infrastructure-changes

Piskurich, G. M. (2015). Rapid instructional design: Learning ID fast and right. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.


Whitehead, B.M., Jensen, D.E.N., and Boschee, F. (2013). Planning for technology: A guide for school administrators, technology coordinators, and curriculum leaders. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press


Vision for School Technology


presentation-1311167_640.jpg


Technology in its own right is just a tool with little inherent learning value. The value of technology is not derived from the tool itself; rather, the learning stems from how the student uses the technology to solve a problem or create a product. In reference to the age old adage, if you put put garbage in, you get garbage out. Likewise, if you only use technology to digitize simple tasks without requiring students to think critically, then the students will never develop their critical thinking skills and continue to produce mediocre work despite whatever technology is used to to produce that work. Furthermore, if teachers do not value the use of technology as transformative teaching practices, then the technology will only be detrimental to student learning. Armistead (2016) argued that school leaders should develop a shared vision and mission statement that integrates technological knowledge with pedagogical knowledge to encourage the transformative use of technology in the classroom. Dedication to a shared vision and mission statement, which encourages technology use as a vehicle for engaging in critical thinking will help students be prepared for a 21st century workforce.

In order to develop a technology vision, school technology leaders should consider a specific technology framework or model to provide context for students, teachers, and parents when viewing the educational process through a technology lens. Whitehead, Jensen, and Boschee (2013) argued that technology leaders should consider these frameworks when developing technology plans, allowing teachers, students, and parents to see how technology is integrated with content and pedagogical knowledge to create a system of learning that encourages critical, 21st century thinking. In this regard, Whitehead, Jensen, and Boschee (2013) explained that the Framework for 21st Century Learning is a, “holistic view of 21st century teaching and learning that combines a focus on student outcomes and innovative support systems to help students master the multidimensional abilities required of them in the 21st century" (p. 88). The concept for this framework is best represented by this graphic taken from the Partnership for 21st Century Learning.

Whitehead, Jensen, and Boschee (2013) explained with this framework, the focus shifts from how the teacher uses technology to deliver content to how students use technology to create or solve complex tasks. Furthermore, the Framework for 21st Century Learning can be used in conjunction with the research-based ISTE standards to help teachers identify essential technology skills for students to be successful. The ISTE standards can be accessed at this link:https://www.iste.org/. In regard to the use of the ISTE standards and the Framework for 21st Century Learning, Armistead (2016) argued that the concurrent use of each model within a shared vision and mission can facilitate transformative technological change within a school. Each framework helps both teachers and students to create a culture collaborative and innovative technology use to promote learning that is applicable in a digital age. Likewise, a commitment to a vision that uses these frameworks foundationally will ensure that students are developing essential 21st century skills.



References


Armistead, S. (2016). Digital technologies: From vision to action. Teachers and Curriculum, 16(1), 1-9.


Whitehead, B.M., Jensen, D.E.N., and Boschee, F. (2013). Planning for technology: A guide for school administrators, technology coordinators, and curriculum leaders. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press.

Using Technology Effectively: Exploring the TPACK Framework

This podcast explores how to use technology effectively in the classroom by exploring the TPACK framework.

Planning Intentional Professional Development

Image result for technology professional development

As with any profession, professional learning is an integral component of developing a teacher’s instructional practice. Unfortunately, poorly designed professional development can be laborious and meaningless when it is not designed to meet the needs of the participants. The same is true for technology professional development. It must be designed intentionally to meet the needs of the participants while staying true to the technology mission and vision statement of the school.Furthermore, Whitehead, Jensen, and Boschee (2013) explained technology leaders should plan technology professional development with five goals in these essential areas: learning, assessment, teaching, infrastructure, and productivity. A detailed explanation of the five essential areas can be found here. Aligning professional development with these goals provides purpose and focus, allowing teachers a greater opportunity for learning.

In regard to learning goals, technology leaders should use strategic assessments to determine the area of need within in a school. Marzano and Simms (2013) argued for the use of strategic assessments to place teachers on a technology use continuum, providing technology coaches with a specific entry point to provide coaching services for that teacher. This concept should be applied when developing school-wide professional development. Sending a strategic survey to teachers before the professional development will provide the technology leader an idea of what the faculty understands in regard to technology use. Aligning this with the learning goal, gives teachers an opportunity to learn about meaningful, transformational technology to use in their classroom. Likewise, the teachers can turn around the information with their students, consequently increasing the digital literacy of their students as well. Using these strategies, would prevent pointless professional development sessions in which the majority of the participants are already proficient with the technology that is being presented.

Likewise, providing a productivity goal allows all participants to see the strategic plan for how technology should be used in the school. In other words, technology should be used intentionally, not just as a replacement for a pencil and graphic organizer. Therefore, technology leaders should plan professional development with the productivity goal in mind, so teachers can use technology transformationally, allowing students the opportunity to plan and development projects using technology. The professional developments should focus on the intentional use of technology in an attempt to move teachers along the technology use continuum, consequently providing substantive opportunities for students to use and develop technology.

Using the five essential areas of focus to create professional development goals provide focus to professional development while aligning the professional development to the vision and mission of the school. The application of these goals ensures that technology will be used transformationally within the school.



References


Marzano, R. and Simms, J. (2013). Coaching classroom instruction. Bloomington, IN: Marzano Research Laboratory.


Whitehead, B.M., Jensen, D.E.N., and Boschee, F. (2013). Planning for technology: A guide for school administrators, technology coordinators, and curriculum leaders. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press.

Creating Substantive Technology Change

This is an audio blog that discusses methods by which school leaders can create substantive technology change within their schools.

You're not in it alone!


https://c2.staticflickr.com/8/7311/27581520632_9476cdb558_b.jpg

c2.staticflickr.com


Instructional coaches fulfill a unique niche within a school. They are required to be transformational leaders by helping teachers improve their teaching practice; however, they have to fulfill this obligation without the ability to require mandates or directives. Without this administrative privilege, it is crucial for instructional coaches to develop and maintain a relationship with their mentee teachers that promotes an environment of self-reflection and growth. This environment helps move teachers along the continuum for their specific growth goal. Therefore, instructional coaches must use strategic approaches when developing these relationships as to not damage the rapport with the teacher while ensuring the teachers are taking the appropriate actions to improve their instruction. Marzano and Simms (2013) reviewed specific aspects of instructional coaching practice to help coaches enter and maintain appropriate relationships with teachers. Specifically, developing coaching conversations and modeling are the two aspects that were crucial for the development of my coaching relationship.

As an administrator, it was difficult for me to develop an appropriate coaching relationship. The teacher for which I engaged in a coaching cycle is my subordinate. That relationship was already established before beginning the coaching cycle. I had to develop a completely different relationship with this teacher while maintaining the administrator-teacher relationship. The establishment of the coaching relationship was necessary because I did not want this teacher to view the coaching strategies as directives, rather I wanted the teacher to view the coaching process strictly as a learning experience to improve their instructional practice. The primary tool in developing this relationship was dialogue. The conversation I developed had to move from a directing conversation to a facilitating and coaching conversation. Word choice was paramount in developing the appropriate conversation in order to reach the desired outcome. I intentionally removed the personal pronoun ‘you’ from the conversation; and instead, I used collective personal pronouns, establishing the idea of a team. Cornett et al. (2009) explained, “no teacher faces an instructional challenge alone" (p. 27). It is important for that teacher to understand that the development of his instructional practice is a group effort.

Furthermore, Marzano and Simms (2013) explained modeling is an important aspect of the coaching process. In order to identify a growth goal for the teacher, I asked him to complete a likert scale, which would place him on the continuum in regard to learning targets. He had completed my previous training on learning targets, and he scored himself high in regard to developing student-friendly learning targets from the standards and his ability to differentiate between a learning objective and a learning target. However, he identified he was not comfortable in developing student buy-in and ownership of the learning target. Therefore, we developed a growth goal that would address his concern. I presented him several strategies in regard to developing student ownership of the standard and we discussed the research that supported these strategies as well. He chose learning target annotation as his next step, so I modeled that process for him, so he could see the strategy in action. As I modeled the strategy, we discussed why each of the different components of strategy were important. He explained that he heard the why of the learning targets on many different occasions, but it never quite clicked until he was able to see the strategy in action. In essence, he needed me to differentiate my instruction based on his specific learning style. When I was able to engage him in this way, he better understood my success criteria for successful implementation of the learning target. This proved that modeling the strategy was necessary in developing understanding. It is simply not enough to tell teachers what to do, rather instructional coaches should be prepared to show and teach along with their mentee teachers. An excellent example of modeling is presented in the video. Although it focuses on modeling strategies for students, the same concept can be applied when modeling strategies for teachers.


References

Marzano, R. and Simms, J. (2013). Coaching classroom instruction. Bloomington, IN: Marzano Research Laboratory.


Cornett, J., Ellison, J., Hayes, C., Killion, J., Kise, J., Knight, J., Reinke, W.M….West, L. (2009). Coaching: Approaches and perspectives. J. Knight (Ed.) Thousand Oaks, Ca: Corwin Press.


The Coaching Continuum: There's a Strategy for That!

https://c6.staticflickr.com/1/653/22711070429_476b4382ac_b.jpg

c6.staticflickr.com


Coaching, like teaching, requires practitioners to manage many working parts in order to develop instructionally sound teaching practices within their school. These parts must work in unison to reach the desired goal. To better manage these parts, the effective teaching model places these teachers on a continuum, while providing specific action steps that coaches can use to move teachers up the continuum. Thus, the ultimate goal of the instructional coach is to move teachers from the not using (0) phase to the innovating (4) phase, providing appropriate corrective strategies without developing resistance from the teacher in the coaching cycle. In order to accurately measure the success of the teacher, instructional coaches must be cognisant of the teacher’s ability to complete specific learning targets and the students’ abilities to perform their learning targets as well. Proper monitoring of these learning targets is crucial to ensure the teacher’s practice is positively affecting student learning. Fortunately, use of instructional technology can attend to both the teacher and student actions, allowing teachers to complete complex tasks while collecting large volumes of student data to inform their instructional practice.

The initial phase of the coaching model requires teachers to complete a self-assessment, which helps them identify classroom strategies or behaviors that could be used as their instructional focus. At this point, the coach should compile appropriate research and strategies that attend to instructional or behavioral focus of the teacher (Marzano & Simms, 2013). Effectively, the teacher is now placed in the continuum at the not using (0) phase; and essentially, the coaches responsibility at this point is to support the instructional focus with research. Marzano and Simms (2013) reported that the coach should unwrap the instructional or behavioral strategy by highlighting the steps and parts of the strategy, which provides the pertinent information of the strategy in smaller, digestible chunks. Although not specific to an instructional strategy, it is important for a technology coach or instructional coach to provide easy access to research on instructional strategies and a snapshot of the strategy as a reference guide. This is best completed by compiling the information using a cloud-based, file sharing system that is easily accessible. Teachers can reference this document to ensure they are aligning their instruction with appropriate components of the strategy. At this point, the teacher has entered the beginning (1) phase of the continuum.

Marzano and Simms (2013) provided design questions that referenced the different areas of focus within the classroom. The first question involved establishing goals, tracking progress, and celebrating success. Each component of this design question can be accomplished using instructional technology. Holland (2013) argued for the development of a flipped classroom. In this model, students are able to use technology to guide their own learning. The flipped classroom model is discussed in detail in the embedded pin.

In regard to establishing goals, Marzano and Simms (2013) reported that goal setting can provide a significant improvement of student achievement. Furthermore, a specific strategy that attends to goal setting is allowing students to develop their own individual learning goals based on the overall learning target. This can be easily accomplished by allowing the student to self-assess their own understanding of the standard through a digital self-assessment that provides student specific data in regard to their understanding of the content. The student could then use that information to construct their own individual learning targets within a flipped classroom setting, allowing the student to engage in their own, self-paced learning. The technology component of this strategy provides, quick data that the student can use immediately to begin their learning.

Likewise, progress tracking is easily accomplished through the use of technology-based instructional strategies. Marzano and Simms (2013) encouraged the frequent use of formative assessments to attend to progress tracking with the students. The goal of formative assessment is to provide timely corrective feedback in order to help guide student learning. This easily accomplished using technology-based instructional strategies. Formative assessments like “Think, Ink, Pair, Share" can be completed digitally, providing timely corrective feedback that could be used by the student to reach their self-constructed learning target. Likewise, peer edits could be completed digitally through cloud-based programs, allowing students to engage in constructive dialogue with one another. Furthermore, the editing process can be tracked using these programs as well, providing an opportunity for students to metacognitively analyze their writing process. This is also an essential component of the flipped classroom. The digital editing process allows students to complete their research at home, providing an opportunity for the teacher to delve in the writing process with the students in class.

Lastly, Marzano and Simms (2013) explained that student success should be celebrated in order to increase student achievement. Fortunately, instructional technology provides a quick and easy avenue to celebrate student success. The use of digital badges is becoming more frequent especially in the flipped classroom model. Digital badges provide an opportunity for teachers to celebrate student success by rewarding students for completing certain tasks. As students collect these badges, their confidence increases, consequently increasing their achievement. Sorenson (2013) argues that accruing badges increases student self-efficacy. Student self-efficacy is important for self-guided instruction like a flipped classroom because it increases the independence of the student. Sorenson elaborates on the use of digital battles in the following video.


Technology-based instructional strategies help coaches guide teachers in the development of their instructional practice, moving them up the effective teaching model continuum. Consequently, student achievement is positively affected by the intentional use of these strategies within the classroom. Although many of these strategies could be completed in an analog system, the digital version provides an opportunity to speed up the process while collecting a large volume of data, which could be used to inform instruction.



References


Holland, B. (2013, October 30). The flipped mobile classroom: Learning "upside down." [Web log comment]. Retrieved from http://www.edutopia.org/blog/flipped-classroom-learning-upside-down-beth-holland


Marzano, R. and Simms, J. (2013). Coaching classroom instruction. Bloomington, IN: Marzano Research Laboratory.


Sorenson, K. (2013, April 24). We need more stinkin' badges (or, how to increase student participation without using grades as a reward).. [Web log comment]. Retrieved from http://keithosorensen.blogspot.com/2013/04/badges.html


Instructional coaching theory and practice: The proof is in the pudding.


The implementation of instructional coaches is a relatively new concept. As with instructional design, the field of education has modified coaching from its sports and business roots to meet the needs of students within a traditional classroom. Marzano and Simms (2013) explained that the purpose of an instructional coach is to help teachers better their practice by providing strategies that help students and develop specific action plans to correct areas that are in need of improvement. With this idea in mind, instructional coaches do not assume administerial roles; rather, they act as guides to help lead teachers to develop their instructional practice. Therefore, instructional coaches help teachers and administrators adopt a growth mindset through which they provide support to help teachers reach their full potential. However, for instructional coaching to be successful, schools must develop specific supports to help teachers maintain their level of practice.

Aguilar (2011) argued they are four essential conditions for instructional coaching to be successful: school culture, structures for collaboration, principal’s view of coaching, and professional development of coaches. You can access her blog post by following this link: http://www.edutopia.org/blog/four-conditions-instructional-coaching-elena-aguilar. Marzano and Simms (2013) reported that many people believe the most important component of instructional coaching is the coachee. In this regard, a school culture that is responsive to change and open to engaging in difficult conversations must be established. Teachers within the school must be willing to analyze assessment data and take it face value, so they use that information formatively to improve their classroom instruction. Likewise, a culture of resistance in which teachers attempt to ‘explain away’ data must be avoided in order to truly have a transformative experience. Reeves (2007) reported, “the first requirement of effective coaching is that the person receiving the coaching agrees that a change in performance will be useful" (as cited in Marzano & Simms, 2013, p. 9). Therefore, a school culture where data and self-assessment are valued must be established before instructional coaching will be successful. Therefore, in regard to instructional coaching practice, instructional coaches must develop data meetings and PLCs in which data analysis is meaningful and purposeful. This is necessary to develop buy-in from teachers. If the instructional coaches are unable to get teachers to see the importance of analyzing student data and engaging in self-assessment, then the rest of the coaching cycle will be seen as a waste of time and effort. Likewise, principals need to see instructional coaching as valuable tool to help improve the level of instructional practice throughout the building.

Specifically, principals should make a concerted effort to express the importance of evaluating student progress and responding to areas that need improvement. Marzano and Simms (2013) argued that principals should not force teachers to work with instructional coaches; rather, they should focus on the teacher’s identified area of growth and offer instructional coaching as a way to help reach their goal. In this sense, instructional coaches should be viewed as an additional tool to provide support for teachers. Furthermore, instructional coaching cycles should not be used punitively; instead, they should be used as a comprehensive tool to better a teacher’s instructional practice.

Likewise, opportunities for collaboration should be provided to develop further the relationship between instructional coach and coachee. Marzano and Simms (2013) argued that trust is an essential component regarding the development of coaching relationships. In order to develop trust, teachers and coaches must have time to collaborate with one another through purposeful conversations in regard to student performance. These intimate conversations in regard to student data will help establish trust between the instructional coach and coachee. The establishment of trust within the relationship will help the instructional coach and the coachees have difficult conversations about areas in which the coachee may struggle.

Aguilar (2011) argued that professional development opportunities are critical component for the practice of instructional coaches as well. Both teachers and instructional coaches must see themselves as lifelong learners in order to reach their full potential as teachers and instructional coaches. Marzano and Simms (2013) argued that one of the jobs of instructional coaches is to help teachers transfer their knowledge from professional development to their classrooms. Likewise, instructional coaches need professional development that helps them act as facilitator through the transference of knowledge from the professional development to the classroom.

Although there is not an abundance of empirical data for the use of instructional coaches in a school system, many would attest that instructional coaches provide many benefits for a school. However, in order for instructional coaching to be successful, coaches must take theory regarding instructional coaching to develop a practical plan for application.




References


Aguilar, E. (2011, May 20). Four conditions essential for instructional coaching to work. [Web log comment]. Retrieved from http://www.edutopia.org/blog/four-conditions-instructional-coaching-elena-aguilar


Marzano, R. and Simms, J. (2013). Coaching classroom instruction. Bloomington, IN: Marzano Research Laboratory.


Reeves, D.B. (2007). Coaching myths and realities. Educational Leadership, 65(2), 89-90.










What have I learned?

As with any discipline, good instructional design requires meticulous planning and preparation in order to develop a cohesive product. In its essence, Piskurich (2015) argued, “Instructional design stripped to its basics is simply a process for helping to create effective training in an efficient manner." (p.1) However, in order for the end product to be effective, instructional design practitioners must be willing to complete the appropriate steps in order to ensure that all participants have a valuable training experience. After careful consideration, I believe the most appropriate steps are outlined by the ADDIE Model, which was used to design the final instructional design product for this class. The ADDIE Model takes a comprehensive approach to instructional design, allowing the designers to assess and evaluate his or her work throughout the training to ensure participants acquire the skill or knowledge presented in the training.

Croxton and Chow (2015) explained the ADDIE Model helped keep designers focused on the training model because the trainers were attentive to the evaluative phase of the ADDIE Model. Therefore, the trainers continuously evaluated the effects of each of the training modules adjusting the training accordingly. Fortunately, educators have identified this practice as good instruction in their classrooms. Unknowingly, most teachers use the ADDIE approach to design lessons. Good teachers issue pre-assessments to determine the skill-level of their students, so they can design specific lessons that are tailored to address the individual needs of the students. They develop instructional objectives and goals from which they design a lesson to meet the needs of those goals. They assess if the student is able to meet the standards of the learning target, and they modify their instruction accordingly based on student needs. Each of these teacher actions corresponds with one of the five instructional phases of the ADDIE Model. Furthermore, the model itself is very resilient. Piskurich (2015) explained that the ADDIE Model has been challenged throughout its inception, but instructional designers continue to use it because of its sound instructional design and practicality. Likewise, educators continue to use the model with slight modification or variance in order to provide quality instruction for students.

Because of my background in education, the application of the ADDIE Model was very easy except for the analysis phase. Ignorantly, I assumed that all of the students in my class had very little knowledge in regard to my subject matter. Furthermore, I convinced myself that I would know more about the content because I spent four years learning about my particular subject in college. This egocentric and condescending view caused me to spend little time on the analysis phase of the ADDIE Model. Consequently, my assumptions placed my students at a disadvantage because I was not willing to concede they could have an adequate understanding of the subject matter. In retrospect, I should have issued pre-assessments to determine how much my students understood the subject matter, so I could develop differentiated lessons tailored to the individual needs of my students. As an administrator, I will be attentive the the analysis phase of the model, ensuring that I design professional development for my staff according to their actual need and not their perceived need. Hopefully, I will create a climate that models the differentiation we require in their classrooms.

Specifically, I have collected data in regard to learning target implementation for my faculty, and I have determined this to be an area of focus for this upcoming school year. The website for the course materials for this training can be accessed at Learning To Love Learning Targets. I have embedded the presentation for the first session here.

Powered by emaze

This particular training will be conducted over the course of two months, and it will be divided into whole group faculty sessions with embedded coaching opportunities throughout the weeks between the whole group trainings. In essence, the training is actually three trainings in one covering the development, implementation, and assessment of learning targets, which was an initiative started by our district last year. Unfortunately, the concept of learning targets is still ambiguous for some, so this will be an areas of focus for our faculty. Each individual training will have a strong digital component, which is consistent with the climate of our school- most of our teachers prefer digital opportunities to learn. Each whole group training will have at least three specific training targets, which the faculty will be required to provide evidence of application. Furthermore, an evaluation component will be included in each phase to determine teachers who may require more rigorous, individual coaching.



References

Piskurich, G. M. (2015). Rapid instructional design: Learning ID fast and right. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.

Croxton, R. A., & Chow, A. S. (2015). Using ADDIE and systems thinking as the framework for developing a MOOC: A case study. Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 16(4), 83.

What's the tool for you?



Piskurich (2015) noted, “the field of instructional design never stops moving or growing" (p.452). Likewise, the tools that are implemented during instructional design are constantly growing as well. Training tools are shifting into the digital realm. With this transformation to the digital realm, participants are able to use traditional analog tools through digital mediums. This allows trainers to make training resources that take advantage of digital media, combining analog and digital resources into a cohesive, dynamic product. Hicks (2013) explained that the practice of crafting digital writing opens further avenues for readers, which is difficult to achieve with traditional writing methods. I believe the same to be true for the analysis of writing as well. Specifically, I was able to the find an digital annotation system to replace the standard analog annotation. The digital annotation system allows users to not only annotate the resource, but they are able to conduct further research in regard to the resource in a quick and efficient manner. Two of these annotating tools are highlighted here.



In addition to the annotation programs highlighted above, the most accessible digital annotation programs is the Google suite of apps. Most of these applications allow users to annotate and collaborative with group members on a single project. Furthermore, many of these apps include the embedded research tool that provides easy access to additional resources while developing the project. These features can be seen in the embedded document.



These annotation programs allow users to annotate on the resource while providing avenues for further research. The annotations can be shared with users, developing a collaborative community that are able to discuss the resource. Furthermore, digital collaboration develops digital communication fluency ("Digital generation," 2009). By developing their digital communication skills, the participants are consequently developing their ability to give timely, and quality feedback while creating meaningful discussions in regard to the digital resource. This concept is a crucial component of my learning target training because I require participants to annotate their learning targets to measure their understanding of the development of learning targets using the appropriate course of study standards. Traditionally, the participants would analyze a printed copy of the learning target; however, with the digital annotation tools the participants can collaborate with one another while annotating their learning target, providing deeper insight to requirements of the learning targets. The collaborative component provides opportunities that are difficult to achieve with a traditional annotation method. Furthermore, I can share digital copies of the graphic organizers and handouts with the participants, which allows them to annotate directly on the digital copy. Using the “find" function of the digital document allows them to access specific information quickly, whereas the printed copies of training materials would require them to sift through multiple documents to find information.

Additionally, Piskurich (2015) explained that trainers can use flipped classrooms to turn around large volumes of information quickly and efficiently. Providing digital access to the documents ahead of time allows participants to review the information and develop specific questions, which deepens their understanding of the source material before the actual training occurs. In this scenario, the trainer does not have to waste time reviewing presentations, rather they can spend their time addressing the specific needs of the participants.

Providing digital resources for participants develops multiple avenues of instruction, which can be used to further understanding during the training. Furthermore, the digital resources and tools encourages collaboration among participants consequently developing their digital communication skills. These skills are essential for all members of the digital community.





References


Digital generation theme: Collaborating. (2009, May 27). Edutopia. Retrieved from


Hicks, T. (2013). Crafting digital writing: Composing texts across media and genres. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.

Piskurich, G. M. (2015). Rapid instructional design: Learning ID fast and right. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.



What strategy works for you?

With a traditional “sit and get" training, participants rarely have an opportunity to engage with information and learning. Consequently, this passive learning inadequately prepares the trainees for the practical application of the information. In short, the method by which the information is delivered is incongruent with the intended use of the information. Piskurich (2015) explained that good instructional designers choose delivery methods that align with the course of objectives. Therefore, if the objectives for the course are performance-based, then the delivery method of the information should reflect the need for the learners to be active participants in order to complete the learning objectives. As a result of the active learning process, participants will develop a more in-depth understanding of the material. Specifically, there are two strategic learning strategies that do an excellent job of engaging learners: case- based (project-based) learning and scenario-based learning. Through each of these strategies, learners are given the opportunity to think critically about the information while using their newly acquired knowledge to solve an essential question or problem.
Cased-based learning or problem-based learning is a strategic learning strategy in which participants are given a specific task or problem to complete. In juxtaposition to “sit and get" training, the participants are tasked with struggling with the information to solve the problem, consequently enriching their understanding of the source material. With this type of strategy, the trainer acts as a facilitatory, clarifying information when necessary, providing guidance when participants are unable to solve a specific component of the problem, and debriefing the participants in regard to the information acquired throughout the learning. Abraham, Damanhuri, and Salehuddin (2016) explained problem-based learning increased self-directed learning in medical students by requiring participants to define their own objectives and outcomes during the learning process, enriching their understanding of the content. Furthermore, Yoo and Park (2015) argued problem-based learning helped foster communication and critical-thinking among nursing school participants. Using case-based (problem-based) learning during trainings has provided opportunities for my faculty members to engage with the information, while developing their communication and critical-thinking skills. Specifically, the teachers were tasked with disaggregating assessment data and developing a screening flowchart that could be used universally throughout the school in order to identify struggling students. The only parameters that were given for the activity were the types of assessments and the percent of students who needed to be identified to adequately service our student population. Teachers worked collaboratively with one another, analyzing the data and developing a comprehensive system that could be used to identify struggling students. This training was successful because initially, the teachers were overwhelmed with the disaggregation of the data; however, throughout the process, the teachers became comfortable with the data analysis. This allowed them to develop a specific program to address the needs of our school while acquiring the data analysis skills needed to address student concerns in their individual classrooms. This is the completed screening flowchart.
Screening Flow Chart (1).png

Similarly, scenario-based learning provides opportunities for learners to actively engage in the learning process through simulation. As with case-based learning, participants have the opportunity to engage with the content knowledge in order to complete a specific task. However, scenario-based learning adds an opportunity to include a technology component as well. Piskurich (2015) argued blended learning opportunities are more successful. Scenario-based learning provides blended learning by utilizing the strategies of case-based learning with a digital learning environment. Furthermore, scenario-based learning provides a protected, digital environment for participants while allowing them to use the information contextually. I had the opportunity to participate in a scenario-based learning opportunity while learning lab safety in college. The professor gave each group of students a specific scenario in which they had to use their knowledge of laboratory procedures to develop a solution. The action steps were entered into a computer program that allowed students to see the results of their actions without causing any harm to the participants. This type of learning is crucial because it developed critical-thinking skills in a high stress situation without the fear of causing harm to the students. Communication was essential during this process, encouraging collaboration among group members and other teams throughout. Likewise, the active engagement and practical application of the information provided greater context for lab safety instructions, emphasizing the importance of proper technique during actual labs.
Through each learning strategy, participants are able to engage in the information providing greater context. The practical application of the information allows the participants to develop their own unique understanding of the information, providing unique perspectives for class discussion. Additionally, both types of trainings encourage the development of critical-thinking skills and collaboration, creating a rich learning experience for the participants.


References

Abraham, R. R., Hassan, S., Ahlam Damanhuri, M. U., & Salehuddin, N. R. (2016). Exploring students' self-directed learning in problem-based learning. Education In Medicine Journal, 8(1), 15-23. doi:10.5959/eimj.v8i1.377


Piskurich, G. M. (2015). Rapid instructional design: Learning ID fast and right. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.

Yoo, M., & Park, H. (2015). Effects of case-based learning on communication skills, problem-solving ability, and learning motivation in nursing students. Nursing & Health Sciences, 17(2), 166-172. doi:10.1111/nhs.12151


What is instructional design?

Instructional design provides focus to a lesson or training by targeted a specific skill and developing measurable objectives to ensure that the skill of concept has been taught to fidelity. Good instructional design includes detailed analysis of needs assessments to determine deficiencies while providing intentional instructional strategies that address the needs of individual learners in the training. Furthermore, trainers must include an assessment measure to identify concepts that need clarification and further instruction. Specifically, a detailed, formulaic model can be applied during instructional design providing the best experience for the learner.

Likewise, Yanchar and Hawkley (2015) argued that instructional designers improve their practice through informal learning, which included discussions with other instructional designers, subject matter experts, and thorough analysis of available products. Through the discussion and analysis of different techniques and models, the instructional designers were able to self-reflect, developing trainings that pulled from practical applications of the techniques discussed in theoretical classes. In this regard, the practice of instructional design is one in which practitioners are constantly evaluating and manipulating their training modules to better suit the needs of the learners. Piskurich (2015) explained that analysis is an integral component to several phases of instructional design models. Specifically, instructional designers must analyze data in regard to not only the identified or perceived need of the institution, but they must be aware of the learners within their training as well in order to provide the most beneficial experience for the participants.

The constant analysis and evaluation used to develop trainings provides an advantage for the use of instructional design by allowing instructional designers to manipulate their programs or modules based on the immediate need of the institution or the individual needs of the learners; this provides concise and meaningful learning for the participants. However, Piskurich (2015) suggested that the amount of time and effort that trainers put into their instructional design may cause them to be unwilling to manipulate their design when their analysis indicates their current model is ineffective. This reluctance could be potentially problematic because the instructional design would not reflect the need of the individual or organization. Despite this disadvantage, when instructional design is completed to fidelity without personal prejudice, it yields substantial results, which benefit both the organization and the individual participant.

The best of example of outstanding instructional design that I have experienced was through AMSTI training, which was partnered with the University of Montevallo. Each day, the instructor posted clear, measurable objectives that were assessed intermittently throughout the training. Furthermore, the instructor used scenario-based instructional strategies that allowed the participants to engage with the material, developing a practical understanding of the learning objectives. Before each break, the instructor gave informal formative assessments to measure our understanding of the material, and she addressed areas of misconceptions with the individuals who were having difficulty, differentiating the material to allow others to move at a faster pace. Each of these elements not only provided a pleasurable experience for the participants, but it provided specific guidance as to how to use the training once returning to the classroom. Although the video is designed to demonstrate the effective use of learning targets, it is a good example as to why defining learning objectives important for instructional designers.

Using a Learning Target throughout a Lesson from EL Education on https://vimeo.com">Vimeo.

On the other hand, I have experienced training that lacked the elements of good instructional design completely. Specifically, I participated in a dyslexia training that did not attend to the level of knowledge of the participants, consequently forcing participants to sit through explanations of dyslexia that they are already knew. The instructor did not post measurable objectives, so it was difficult to identify the purpose of the presentation. Also, the instructor did not measure the acquisition of knowledge, so she did not know if we understood the training or not. Unfortunately, I left the training confused as to what I was supposed to do with the information that was presented.

Excellent content presentation is no substitute for quality instructional design, which is why most school systems have adopted instructional practices that model instructional design techniques. Through thorough analysis of the needs of the organization and the development of a detailed action plan, instructional designers are able to create robust trainings that meet the needs of all participants while focusing on a specific goal for the betterment of the entire organization.


References


Piskurich, G. M. (2015). Rapid instructional design: Learning ID fast and right. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.


Yanchar, S. C. & Hawkley, M. N. (2015). Instructional design and professional informal learning: Practices, tensions, and ironies. Educational Technology & Society, 18(4), 424–434.


Crafting Social Media Texts

Social media is a powerful tool that provides an opportunity to develop discourse, which can be transformative. However, most individuals do not take the time to craft carefully their dialogue, weakening their argument. Due to the reactionary nature of most social media interactions, many educators shy away from using it as a tool in the classroom; however, when carefully crafted, social media can be used as an engaging platform that can act as springboard for quality writing pieces. Careful analysis of a social media interaction using the MAPS heuristics will provide insight in regard to crafting and enhancing social media posts to help students engage in powerful conversations.


Tumblr is a social media outlet that acts as a microblogging platform in which users are able to post and comment on different forms of media. Furthermore, users can engage in conversations about the the posts using the comment feature of the service. In the post How do we fix education: Listen to young people, Kouns and Loitz (2013) describe a program in which they travel the United States listening to young people’s perspective in regard to education reform; the original post can be found at https://www.good.is/articles/how-can-we-fix-education-listen-to-young-people. Using the MAPS heuristic as a lens, the media used to craft the text is a microblogging platform, which is appropriate for the content. The authors develop a multimodal piece that combines both informative and narrative writing, which lends itself to the emotional appeal of the audience. Unfortunately, despite the repeated reference to student voice, the authors do not include video or audio of the student voices, which would lend itself to further establishing an emotional investment in the piece by the audience. Hicks (2013) argued that the use of multiple forms of media in a digital text can enhance the message of the digital writer. In this case, the use of video or audio would greatly enhance the overall effect of the piece, providing tangible evidence of how students feel about education.


Furthermore, the inclusion of the blog through Tumblr allows for widespread distribution of the article through other social media platforms like Facebook and Twitter. The ability of the authors to disseminate the information through multiple platforms is important to saturate the Internet with their message; unfortunately, the original blogging website did not provide a comment system from which the audience could engage in a discourse concerning the information from their original blog posting. In regard to the MAPS heuristic, the authors did not attend to needs of their audience, which detracts from the overall piece. Publishing the writing digitally requires the authors to develop a forum in which to discuss the content of their piece. Hicks (2013) explained that the purpose of any social media outlet in education should be to engage in conversation about the subjects, allowing students to be analytical and communicative. Without the comment feature, the audience is not able to interact with the text, preventing dialogue that could potentially lead to additional discovery in regard student voices in education. Omar, Zube, and Lampe (2012) reported that social media can be used as a foundation for civic engagement, developing a community that is driven by a common purpose. The same idea can be applied to social media as an educational tool, but this is only effective when the audience is able to engage in the conversation. Ironically, deactivating the comment section for this blog post negatively impacts the intended message by silencing the voices of those who would like to engage in the conversation of empowering student voices in education. Fortunately, the Tumblr community was able to engage in conversation through the “like" section of the Tumblr page. A sample of the dialogue is included for analysis.

The “like" section provides the much needed opportunity for the community to engage in a discourse in regard to the original blog. The engagement with the text allows other educators to analyze and provide commentary, which leads to the synthesis of new ideas. Furthermore, the information can be retweeted and shared on Tumblr, furthering the discussion.


In general, the Tumblr blog post was a good use of social media, but the piece could have been enhanced through the use of additional media and a discussion platform. The use of video or audio in the blog post could greatly enhance the overall message of the piece, while a discussion forum could provide an opportunity to develop discourse in which the content could be explored in more depth.



References


Hicks, T. (2013). Crafting digital writing: Composing texts across media and genres. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.

Kouns, C. & Loitz,D. (2013, June 3). How can we fix education? Listen to young people. [Web log comment]. Retrieved from https://www.good.is/articles/how-can-we-fix-education-listen-to-young-people

Obar, J.A., Zube, P. & Lampe, C. (2012). Advocacy 2.0: An analysis of how advocacy groups in the United States perceive and use social media as tools for facilitating civic engagement and collective action. Journal of Information Policy, 2, 1–25. http://doi.org/10.5325/jinfopoli.2.2012.0001





Crafting Video Texts


In college, my favorite elective class was film history and motion picture criticism. Originally I joined the class because it was two days a week, one of which was a two hour movie extravaganza. I assumed that we would watch classic movies like Casablanca; I did not expect to watch modern movies like Platoon. Despite the obvious differences between the two movies, they each had common elements that made them superior movies. Each filmmaker paid careful attention to their craft when making these pieces. Likewise, digital writers must be mindful of their craft when creating their pieces. Unfortunately, I did not pay any attention to the craft of my video when completing the original introduction video. For the second go around, I considered the MAPS heuristic as a road map for completing the video. Specifically, I paid careful attention to transitions and sound, which were outlined during the storyboard process.
Hicks (2013) divided the crafting of digital video texts into three specific components: prewriting and drafting, revising and editing, and publishing and assessing. Often times, teachers de-emphasize the importance of the prewriting and drafting phase. Hicks (2013) encourages digital writers to script and storyboard their pieces before beginning the filming process. The storyboarding process provides a visual outline for the video text, allowing the digital writer a holistic perspective of the overall piece while minimizing the time spent revising and editing. Furthermore, alterations to the piece are much easier to make during the prewriting and storyboard phase for composing digital video texts. Animator, Jazza argued the importance of using storyboards and explained how to use the storyboard process to craft digital animations in this video.


Although the storyboarding process in presented in digital format in the video, it still provides an opportunity for viewers to see how the storyboarding processes forcers digital writers to evaluate the principles for crafting quality video texts. Fortunately for less advanced users, the storyboarding process can be completed on pen and paper as well. Regardless of the medium, it is an integral component of crafting digital video texts that must be addressed when digital writers develop their video. For the revision, I created a storyboard, so I could develop a holistic picture of how I wanted my introduction to look. Furthermore, I drafted a more detailed script, outlining transitions and the images associated with the dialogue. Likewise, I was able to choose music that I felt would help enhance the story by creating a specific mood. Creating this storyboard, provided an opportunity for me to develop a more cohesive picture of my final product. Hicks (2013) suggested that these elements add to the crafting of the video, developing an overall aesthetically pleasing video text.

Likewise, Hicks (2013) argued that revising and editing videos is an important component when crafting digital video texts. With seemingly limitless amount of digital composition tools, students have access to an unending supply of text transitions, slide transitions, sounds, and animations, all of which may be overwhelming to novice video text producers. Similar to crafting digital presentations, digital writers must pay attention to the use of these different devices so each enhances the overall meaning of the video without being distracting to viewers. The revision and editing process helps digital video creators to ensure their work is purposeful while maintaining aesthetic appeal. Hicks (2013) argued that the editing process is like proofreading a paper; it requires the distinguishing eyes of several editors looking for several different components. In most situations, students stop the editing process after one peer review, which in most cases is insufficient. It takes several opportunities to for active readers to search for errors. Furthermore, editors should be given a specific focus for each edit, allowing them a more focused lens from which to critique the work. Baepler and Reynolds (2014) examined the editing process by allowing peers to annotate directly onto video, which led to a greater level confidence for students who produced videos for comment. In a digital world where video edits are easily accessible, it is crucial for digital writers to present their draft videos for edit and comment in order to craft a piece with a small margin of error. In alignment with the basic principles for drafting video texts, I bit the bullet and published my video so others could view it in all of its glory. And despite the initial horror of allowing others to review and critique my video, I solicited help from several of friends, family, and colleagues to review my introduction, which led me to develop the video through a different medium. This new presentation medium flowed more like a presentation and less like a forced confession during an interrogation, which should be more enjoyable to the viewers. Furthermore, I included transitions that flowed better than the previous ones- at least, that was what I was told by the editors. At this point, I changed the background music to align more with the mood of the piece, which increased the narrative power of the video text.

Finally, digital video writers must be cognizant of how and where they publish their videos. In regard to editing, it is best practice for digital writers to publish their videos on websites that allow for commentary in order to hone their craft. Although it is difficult to review criticism of one’s work, it is a necessary component of becoming not only a digital videoer but a digital writer as well. Likewise, publishing videos in forums that include peers, creates a community that is determined to better their craft collectively- free of the prejudice and condescension of internet trolls. Likewise, an objective measure to assess digital video is essential. Viewers must be privy to objective analysis of content; if not, then the measurement of the art becomes nothing more than a “like" or “dislike" on a social media site. Hicks (2013) argued for an analysis of the craft of the piece to be a component of the overall quality of the final product. How the video is made can be just as important as the overall message of the piece.

Considering the essential principles of crafting digital video, I reviewed my initial introduction video posted at the beginning of class. I can honestly say that I did not follow any of the principles outlined by Hicks. Furthermore, the video did not contain elements other than me rambling about myself, which is dull. After careful consideration, I have crafted a digital video that aligns with the principles of crafting digital video. Although I am still a novice, I hope that I was able to view the piece objectively, developing a video that is worth watching.



References


Hicks, T. (2013). Crafting digital writing: Composing texts across media and genres. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.


Baepler, P., & Reynolds, T. (2014). The digital manifesto: Engaging student writers with digital video assignments. Computers and composition, 34, 122-136. doi:10.1016/j.compcom.2014.10.002